search
Home / True Crime / Nobody Should Believe Me

Latest Episodes

filter_list
The Warrior Eli Hoax Part 1 with Taryn Wright
New Jan 08, 2026 45 min EXPLICIT

The Warrior Eli Hoax Part 1 with Taryn Wright

In the early 2010s, a heartbreaking story circulated widely online: a family documenting their young son Eli’s battle with cancer, following the sudden death of his mother. When investigative write...

Justina Pelletier Part 2 with Beau Berman (rebroadcast)
Jan 02, 2026 47 min EXPLICIT

Justina Pelletier Part 2 with Beau Berman (rebroadcast)

In part 2 of Andrea’s Justina Pelletier coverage, she’s joined by Beau Berman, the reporter that broke this story. *** On this show we talk a lot about how Munchausen by Proxy cases are covered i...

Justina Pelletier Part 1 (rebroadcast)
Jan 01, 2026 52 min EXPLICIT

Justina Pelletier Part 1 (rebroadcast)

As 2025 comes to a close and we look forward to season 7, we’re airing the first part of Andrea’s coverage on the Justina Pelletier case—the case that opened the Pandora’s Box of medical kidnapping...

Jesika Jones Part 2 with Derek Jones (rebroadcast)
Dec 26, 2025 54 min EXPLICIT

Jesika Jones Part 2 with Derek Jones (rebroadcast)

In the second episode of Andrea’s coverage of the Jesika Jones case, she’s joined by Derek Jones, Jesika’s then-husband. Derek bravely tells the story of how he and Jesika met, their home life, and...

Jesika Jones Part 1 with Detective Mike Weber (rebroadcast)
Dec 25, 2025 1h 5m EXPLICIT

Jesika Jones Part 1 with Detective Mike Weber (rebroadcast)

Today we’re re-airing part 1 of the Jesika Jones case in Texas. Look out for part 2 with the father, Derek Jones, in the feed tomorrow!  *** This week on case files, Andrea is joined by Dete...

Catching Up with Mishelle and Aunt Sabrina
Dec 19, 2025 1h 20m EXPLICIT

Catching Up with Mishelle and Aunt Sabrina

In this follow-up to Season 6, Andrea reconnects with Mishelle and her aunt Sabrina to talk about life after sharing Collin’s story. They reflect on what it’s been like to have this information&nbs...

What “The Preventionist” Left Out with Dr. Randy Alexander
Dec 12, 2025 1h 26m EXPLICIT

What “The Preventionist” Left Out with Dr. Randy Alexander

In this episode, we close out our coverage of Serial’s The Preventionist with Dr. Randy Alexander, one of the most experienced child abuse pediatricians in the country and the former supervisor of ...

How Do We Prevent Child Abuse? With Kathleen Strader
Dec 04, 2025 1h 2m EXPLICIT

How Do We Prevent Child Abuse? With Kathleen Strader

This week we’re re-releasing Andrea’s conversation with Kathleen Strader from Prevent Child Abuse America. While Nobody Should Believe Me is, at its core, raising awareness about Munchausen by Prox...

The Human Cost of “The Preventionist” with Dr. Sally Smith
Nov 27, 2025 1h 15m EXPLICIT

The Human Cost of “The Preventionist” with Dr. Sally Smith

In this episode, Dr. Sally Smith is back on the mic to share her reaction to the recent appellate ruling that overturned the massive judgment against Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital in the Ma...

Introducing: Dakota Spotlight Season 12
Nov 21, 2025 9 min EXPLICIT

Introducing: Dakota Spotlight Season 12

Meanwhile in Mankato: Lies, Silence & Murder in Minnesota In 1965, a teenager killed a gas-station clerk near Mankato and was sentenced to forty years. He served five. Decades later, Dakota S...

Dr. Jessica Pryce on the Harms of the Child Welfare System
Nov 20, 2025 42 min EXPLICIT

Dr. Jessica Pryce on the Harms of the Child Welfare System

In light of the overturned ruling of Kowalski v Johns Hopkins and Serial’s The Preventionist, we’re reairing an episode from our Kowalski season in which Andrea dives into the complexities around r...

Kowalski v Johns Hopkins overturned with Ethen Shapiro
Nov 06, 2025 57 min EXPLICIT

Kowalski v Johns Hopkins overturned with Ethen Shapiro

In this episode, Andrea sits down with Ethen Shapiro, trial counsel for Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital, to unpack the landmark appellate decision overturning the $200 million verdict in the ...

Case Files 25: Olivia Gant Part 2
Oct 31, 2025 44 min

Case Files 25: Olivia Gant Part 2

In this episode, Andrea continues delving into the Olivia Gant case with Detective Melissa Kalish, who uncovered the vast fraud and abuse behind Kelly Turner’s lies. Kelly continued to exploit comp...

Abuse Survivors and Victims Deserve Better than 'The Preventionist'
Oct 29, 2025 47 min EXPLICIT

Abuse Survivors and Victims Deserve Better than 'The Preventionist'

In response to Serial Productions’s series The Preventionist, we’re re-airing our episode “What’s Happening in Lehigh?”, where Andrea and Dr. Marc Feldman dive into the claims of “overdiagnosis” of...

Case Files 25: Olivia Gant Part 1
Oct 23, 2025 55 min EXPLICIT

Case Files 25: Olivia Gant Part 1

The disturbing parallels between Collin McDaniel and Olivia Gant's cases led Andrea to speak with Melissa Kalish, the lead detective in the investigation of Kelly Turner, for season 6. Now we’re di...

Introducing: Affirmative Murder
Oct 17, 2025 1h 33m EXPLICIT

Introducing: Affirmative Murder

This week Fran and Alvin discuss food, Pakistan, and American history. *** Listen to Affirmative Murder: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/340-em-eye-ess-ess-eye-pee-pee-eye/id1296864488 Lear...

Answering Your Season 6 Questions
Oct 16, 2025 1h 14m EXPLICIT

Answering Your Season 6 Questions

In this episode, Andrea and the Nobody Should Believe Me team reflect on the emotional impact of making season 6 and the ethical considerations of reporting on Collin’s story. They also address lis...

Introducing: Fruitloops
Oct 10, 2025 1h 7m EXPLICIT

Introducing: Fruitloops

Two cousins. Four murders. One homicidal summer. In 2004, Angel Ford-Wright & Caroline Peoples lured victims with false promises, then executed them. One confessed. One went to trial. Both got ...

True Story Media Presents: Fruitloops
Oct 09, 2025 1h 7m EXPLICIT

True Story Media Presents: Fruitloops

Welcome to the final installment of True Story Media Presents! This week Andrea is talking to Wendy and Beth, the creators behind Fruitloops: Serial Killers of Color. The three of them chat about h...